How Ferrari ignored Twitter, at their peril

I admit it, I am an F1 fan. And like many other F1 fans around the world, I sat down to watch the grand prix this weekend at Hockenheim. And like 95% of F1 fans, I was pretty hacked-off with Ferrari’s decision to give team orders, and switch Alonso and Masa. If you don’t know what I am talking about, and you want to find out – read this BBC article on the race (but in summary, Masa was in the lead and Alonso second. Alonso couldn’t pass Masa so Ferrrari gave a “hidden” message, or team order, for Masa to let Alonso through. This is in breach of F1 rules, as well as poor sportsmanship. They subsequently denied everything after the race).
I personally am a big fan of Masa’s. I just like the guy, and have huge respect for him coming back to racing after his accident. I am not a big fan of Alonso, especially since he was at McLaren and acted the way he did. His continual moaning this season hasn’t helped his cause in my opinion either. So I wanted Masa to win (despite being a McLaren fan). I think most of the know world did, Masa deserved it. It was a year after his accident and it would have been a fitting (almost divine) result and I would imagine that even the F1 drivers would agree with me.
Like thousands of other people around the world, I expressed my thoughts on Twitter. Then when I saw the team order, I was outraged – probably more because I like Masa more than Alonso if I am honest than the bad sportsmanship. I really felt for the guy.
Where Ferrari missed it
So I put that on Twitter too and perhaps this is where Ferrari missed it. They ignored Twitter. The ability for the world to communicate has massively changed, even in the few years since the Michael Schumacher incident that caused the F1 rule to be made. Within an instant you can gauge how the world felt about what had happened. The commentators knew how people felt, the press knew how people felt and so in the interviews after the race, they absolutely pounded into Ferrrari.
(I also think Ferrari underestimated the feeling that the world has toward Masa).
Ferrari’s response was to deny it all with a bunch of weak lies, in effect calling most of the world stupid for believing what they saw. This really got people’s backs up.
What Ferrari have since done
Since that day, Ferrari have been fined $100,000 (the biggest fine that can be made) and it has also been referred to World Motorsport Council for a hearing that is likely to take place in August. But as of yet, I have seen no apology from Ferrari.
On the contrary, I read in the press today that:
Ferrari president Luca di Montezemolo has slammed the “hypocrisy” of those who have criticised Fernando Alonso’s victory in Sunday’s German Grand Prix.
BBC
In the article, the Ferrari president is quoted as saying (from the Ferrari website):
”These things have happened since the days of (Tazio) Nuvolari (a Ferrari driver in the 1930s) and I experienced it myself when I was sporting director, in the days of Niki Lauda.
“Therefore, enough of this hypocrisy, even if I can well believe that some people might well have liked to see our two drivers eliminate one another, but that is definitely not the case for me or indeed for our fans.
What I read here is an acknowledgement that these orders were made but again without apology. No mention of the lies they told. No mention of the damage to the sport’s reputation. No mention of the theft of Masa’s possible first win. No mention of how they treated people like fools. Just an arrogance that claims the rest of the world is hypocritical. (It maybe, Luca, but that still doesn’t excuse your company’s actions).
What Ferrari should have done
I think that the world is to open for large companies to operate in a way that doesn’t listen to the people. They fall too quickly. In an instant Ferrari would have know what people were thinking and should have given a second team order telling the drivers to swap back. Then they should have gone to the interviews saying, “We messed up, we realised we did and so during the race we tried to rectify it. We apologise to the fans and will take the consequences of our actions without excuse.”
They could have done that if they had bothered to check the sentiment of people. This would have been a massive PR boost for them, and they would have won on every level.
I don’t know about the team orders rule. Should it stay or should it go? It is a whole other debate. For me that is not so much the issue – but what is the issue is how Ferrari have responded and dealt with the people. The people have a massive voice through the media these days, it counts more than ever. Apple recently discovered this with their iPhone 4 fiasco and the nonsense they peddled. It has set them back years on the trust scale. I can’t help but think that Ferrari’s PR needs to learn from this.
Takeaway
- Listen to what people are saying and then act accordingly. Don’t not listen and then tell people a bunch of reasons why they are wrong.
- Lying is pointless! Tell the truth, face the consequences and move on.









